For once, I actually think the Oscars focused on the movies than themselves. Generally we get the usual AMPAS President’s speech, the nod to the ballot counters, and the usual stupid tripe like a montage of animal actors. This year, we got a lot of new surprises and a much more intimate setting.
What I liked:
- Introductions to each nominated actor with a charming ass-kiss for each one. Sure, it was cheesy sometimes (and horribly canned in others), but it was a great push towards recognizing everyone in full frame instead of the usual boxes. Huge kudos for this new concept since we also get to see five previous Oscar winners on stage as well.
- More showcasing of each film during the introduction to the nominees of each category. More about the films is better. This is a show based around them after all.
- Closer and smaller stage made things feel intimate. I hated the gigantic staircase and cold demeanor of the old stage. This feels like the nominees are allowed to be in the shot more often.
- Hugh Jackman is a charmer, though I hated the “Musical is Back” segment. Wonderful nods to silliness (”I am Wolverine” and the whole cheap Oscars shtick) were much appreciated given the uptight nature of the Academy.
- The “magic trick” from the Man on Wire win.
- Faster pacing by having several categories introduced by one set of presenters. Loved this and loved the set change for each group of categories. Absolutely awesome concept.
- Nobody was played off.
- All montages were about the films of 2008 rather than some strange topic. Finally we get something that makes sense. Sure, they played segments from Space Chimps and The Clone Wars, but it’s fine since at least they weren’t being snooty about it.
- The Deceased roll is now including movie critics.
What I didn’t like:
- The previously mentioned “Musical is Back” segment. Tripe.
- The ass-kiss segments were really great…when they worked. Some were just so ridiculously canned, you felt bad for the nominee.
- No official musical score selections for each winner. WTF, Michael Giacchino. I expected better from you! >:(
- Really awkward song mash-up sequence. I would have preferred 1.5 minute segments of each song and that’s it. (Though The Boss not being there was also a crime)
- Finally I thought we found the right way to keep audience members from playing favorites during the Deceased film roll, but near the end we still got the favoritism. :(
How did I do on picks? I missed 4 categories I usually always get. I called Adrian Brody over Daniel Day-Lewis and Jack Nicholson that one year. I called all the short films correctly two years in a row. I even called The Lives of Others over Pan’s Labyrinth. But this year? I miss two short films, Actor, and Foreign Language Film with the last one being the only *big* surprise this year. It would have been amazing to have a perfect ballot, though it’s not like this year was surprising at all.
